Car TalkIndustry knowledge5 Cars That Shouldn’t Be Automatic

5 Cars That Shouldn’t Be Automatic

In recent times, automatic transmissions have been slowly replacing manual ones and with good reason. They are easier to use since the driver doesn’t have to work the clutch into the process of shifting gears. They are also less restrictive, allowing the driver some freedom when driving. But perhaps the most important advantage of an automatic transmission car is that it provides an opportunity for less experienced drivers to navigate easily, as well as providing an easy way for those with a disability to drive.

But there are some cars that don’t work well with an automatic gearbox. The following are 5 cars that are far better manual than automatic.

1. Toyota GT86

The Toyota GT86 comes in both manual and automatic. But the manual version is so much better in terms of performance. For instance, it takes 8.2 seconds for the automatic GT86 to go from 0- 60 mph, with a top speed of 130mph. The manual, on the other hand, takes just 7.6 seconds to go from 0- 60 mph, with a top speed of 140mph. It may not seem like much of a difference until you consider the GT86 is a rear-wheel drive sports car. Most people will buy it for its acceleration and speed. 

Toyota GT86 for sale
The Toyota GT86 comes in both manual and automatic (Photo: Flickr)

2. Smart Roadster

Unlike most other two-seaters of its caliber, the Roadster doesn’t offer a choice; it only comes in automatic. It has a 6-speed semi-automatic transmission and paddle shifters, although the automatic make-up of the transmission makes the shifts rather slow. It’s a great lightweight vehicle at just 790kg but the manual transmission most two-seater car enthusiasts look for would have been an added advantage. 

3. MK4 Toyota Supra

The twin-turbo 2JZ Engine and a 6-speed manual gearbox in the Supra make it a legend. The automatic version of the MK Supra is, however, not that great. It comes with an upward limit of 500 horsepower, and as such it lacks the tuning ability of the manual version. Which is probably why it costs nearly half the manual’s price. 

MK4 Toyota Supra for sale
The automatic version of the MK Supra is however not that great (Photo: Flickr)

4.Mercedes Benz C63 AMG

The 6.8-liter V8 engine on the Mercedes-Benz C63 AMG sedan would have worked so much better had there been a manual transmission option. It’s a shame this car only comes as an automatic transmission car, especially because rivals like BMW’s M3 and Audi’s RS4 both provide manual options. But a continued rise in its popularity shows Mercedes-Benz customers really didn’t mind, although it would have been great of Mercedes-Benz to offer a manual transmission option.

5. Mazda Miata

Not a fast car to begin with, the Miata in automatic just further adds to the problems of performance. Plus, the automatic gearbox just doesn’t offer any new or over-the-top technology. When compared to the manual version, the automatic Miata just seems to slow down an otherwise great-performing car.

Mazda Miata for sale
The MX-5 gearbox demonstrates the main reason the Miata should never have come in automatic. (Photo: Flickr)

The MX-5 gearbox clearly demonstrates the main reason the Miata should never have come in automatic. This manual gearbox is one of the best, offering short and precise throws that an automatic Miata lacks.

So, while an automatic transmission car may come with a lot of benefits, it may also reduce performance and handling in some vehicles. When you’re buying a car for its power, acceleration and speed, an automatic transmission is probably not the best choice. Manual gears give you better control of the vehicle, and when a car is built for speed, you want the control a manual gear-shift system will provide.

Philipp Meister
Philipp Meister
Philipp Meister is a valuable member of the Car From Japan blogger team. With a degree in Automotive Technology from the Technical University of Munich and over 20 years of experience as a technician at various Volkswagen dealerships, Philipp brings a wealth of knowledge to his writing. A lifelong car enthusiast, he offers insightful discussions and keeps readers informed on the latest automotive trends. If you're passionate about cars, Philipp's blog is a must-read.
RELATED ARTICLES

5 COMMENTS

    • He already mentioned that autos suffer in performance. Older autos sap a lot of power from the engine, 90s ones can see as much as 30% of the engine’s total power output taken up just by the auto alone.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

referral program

Most Popular