Car TalkDriving TipsWhy Is It So Hard to Shift Into First Gear Unless at...

Why Is It So Hard to Shift Into First Gear Unless at A Dead Stop?

First gear is crucial for starting your car from a standstill, so when it suddenly becomes difficult to engage, it’s a clear sign that something needs attention. It’s not just an inconvenience; it can point to specific issues within your car’s transmission or clutch system. The question “Why is it so hard to shift into first gear?” has several potential answers. We’ll look into what could be causing this stubborn shifting.

Why Is It Hard to Shift Into First Gear?

Usually, in a manual transmission, the first gear is only used for starting the vehicle. This is because the first gear is unsynchronized, and the ratio difference between the first and second gears is too large. What does “ratio” mean here? Well, before that, let’s understand the concept of “synchronization.”

It is the process of shifting directly from one gear to another by pressing the clutch pedal. However, if the gears are not synchronized, the process will make it difficult to shift gears. Now, turning to the concept of the ratio in transmission, let’s consider an example.

In an advanced car, the first gear’s ratio is 3.6:1. This means the gear completes one rotation on every 3.6 rotations of the crankshaft. Similarly, for the second, third, fourth, fifth, and sixth gear, the set ratio is 2.1:1, 1.4:1, 1:1, 0.8:1, and 0.7:1, respectively.

With this defined ratio, you can observe that the difference between the gear ratios gets smaller as you go to higher gears. In other words, it’s easy to shift into a new higher gear, as they are able to match up the engine speed every time you change it.

You can simply understand, there are several reasons which could make it hard to put into first gear: 

Clutch issues

A worn-out clutch, a faulty clutch master, or air in the hydraulic system can be the culprit that makes the clutch pedal lose its function. And that is also the reason why you have trouble when shifting into first gear. Sometimes the cause can come from the clutch fluid. If you detect that the clutch fluid has run out, you should fill it up timely manner to avoid clutch wear and tear due to the lack of clutch fluid. 

why is it hard to shift into first gear
Why is it hard to shift into first gear (Photo: istockphoto)

Shifter problem

When you check and detect if the shifter linkage is damaged or worn, it can be another reason why it is so hard to shift into first gear. Other than that, the shifter may not be aligned properly with the gears, which could make it hard to engage them. 

Low transmission fluid 

Another familiar cause is the low transmission fluid; this problem always causes drivers to shift, including the first gear. The reason is due to the leakage in the transmission system, or you forgot to fill the transmission fluid as recommended by automakers.

low car transmission fluid
This problem always causes drivers to shift including the first gear (Photo: istockphoto)

Having trouble with synchronizer problem

If your car uses a manual transmission, you will easily experience this problem. A manual transmission uses the synchronizer to match the speed of the gear before it engages. Over time, the synchronizer can be worn out and damaged, and the vehicle will have trouble shifting in first gear. 

It’s not easy for you to diagnose exactly the reasons why this issue is happening, so let a trusted mechanic help you and have the necessary repair. 

Hard to Shift into First Gear: Solution

The ultimate solution to downshift the gear from second to first involves a double-clutching process (as said earlier). In other words, you need to bring the car into neutral directly from the second gear and then move into the first gear. For better comprehension, look at the systematic procedure below:

  • Press the clutch pedal,
  • Move the shifter from second to neutral,
  • Release the clutch pedal,
  • Again, press the clutch pedal,
  • Move the shifter from neutral to first now, and
  • Finally, release the clutch pedal.

Following this method will avoid any damage to the transmission, as the speed of the engine will be able to match the gear speed. For the drivers of automatic cars, this issue shouldn’t cause any worries. The downshift from second to first gear is performed automatically.

Watch the video to learn more about the process of fixing this problem:

FAQs

Can you shift into first gear while moving?

It’s generally best to avoid shifting from second gear into first while your car is still moving because it’s hard on the transmission. The big difference between these gears means the synchronizers, which help them mesh smoothly, get overworked. Since you rarely need to do this, skipping it helps keep those parts from wearing out too fast.

Can you go downhill in first gear?

Yes, you can go downhill in first gear. It provides the strongest engine braking, which is very helpful for controlling your speed on steep descents and reducing wear on your brakes. Just make sure you’re at a suitably low speed before shifting into it.

What does it mean when your gear shift is hard to move?

A hard-to-move gear shift generally means there’s an issue with the clutch system (if it’s a manual), the shift linkage or cables, low transmission fluid, or internal transmission problems that are preventing smooth gear engagement.

Finally, I hope these gear-changing driving tips are helpful in resolving the problem of hard to shift into first gear. And, extend the life of the transmission system in your beloved car.

Matsumoto Naoki
Matsumoto Naoki
Matsumoto Naoki is a senior car blogger at Car From Japan. With a background in mechanical engineering, including experience as a Mechanical Design Engineer at Subaru Corporation, he offers a unique perspective on automotive innovations. Matsumoto's articles provide clear, DIY-friendly instructions and how-to guides to help you confidently maintain your car and save money on repairs. His approachable writing style makes even complex mechanical topics accessible to everyone.
RELATED ARTICLES

3 COMMENTS

  1. Thanks for your explanation. I have the same issue with my car when approaching the speed breaker, i slow down my car and then shift the car into first gear this makes grinding sound for one second at approx speed of 20 km/h because speed breaker is also on slope higher . So
    1. If I use the the double clutch technique ,it will not make sound?
    2. Will I have to give some accelerator or not during this process?

    Please guide me for better technique of shifting from second to first during slowing down to avoid grinding sound.

  2. I am a beginner driver and faced same issue time & again. Your explanation is surprising, thanks. You may also make a YouTube video for learners on the said subject…
    I will contact you people in future to purchase a cheaper but latest model car… Thanks for the information shared with us 👍

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular